Published in KARISMA magazine issue 24. This is the original reply in English. It took me some times to come up with the questions. I hope it add some extra information to your Dream Theater library. Replied by John Petrucci.
---------------------
Dream Theater – Karisma Magazine [http://www.majalahkarisma.com] (Malaysia)
We know that John Petrucci, John Myung, and Mike Portnoy started this while attending the Berklee College of Music. What we don't know is that whether dropping out of college to play fulltime was a hard decision? How do you reflect it now? Will you suggest this decision to those who have the same urge?
It was definitely a difficult decision to make. We were young and passionate but our parents wanted us to follow through with our degrees. It took some convincing! Fortunately it turned out to be the right decision but I don’t necessarily advocate dropping out of college for everyone.
Was the decision to play to a more progressive approach in Dream Theater due to the existing talents? How hard was it to be recognized when the album When Dream And Day Unite was released?
We fell into our style very naturally right from the beginning. We were big fans of Rush and Yes as well as many prog/fusion artists. That, combined with our love of metal defined our sound. WDADU really didn’t receive much press. We also didn’t tour in support of it so a lot of people weren’t aware that it was out there.
In Images and Words, the direction of the band is more coherent resulting in the success of the album as well as the band. What was the main approach for that album?
We really just honed in our writing and style for that album. We focused not only on the intricacies of the music, but on the compositions and melodies as well. As a young band, it was a huge help having David Prater produce us.
Awake is a bit dark and some says it was due to Kevin Moore's unwillingness to complete the album. Probably the band was in a difficult situation in trying to catch up with the success of Images and Words. Any reflections on that?
The main contributing factor to the darker and heavier direction was the introduction of the 7-string guitar in our music. Kevin’s departure was certainly heartbreaking but he did complete the album. We had a great time recording in Los Angeles.
When David Prater produced A Change of Seasons, the production was a little bit thin although it fits with the overall compositions. The EP was a little bit out compare to the previous albums which are quite heavy. Was that an agreement between the band and the producer?
David produced ACOS the way he heard it. I’m not sure why he changed direction a bit from IAW but I think in the end it could have been a bit more polished sounding.
Although Falling Into Infinity was regarded as an album which is too commercial, it has many of the Dream Theater's progressiveness trademark. Portnoy hated it. Personally I loved it. To whom you are in agreement with (me or Mike)?
Not speaking for MP but I highly doubt he hated it if I were to speculate. Every one of our albums is a proud moment in our creative lives and I think FII is no exception. Some of our best songs are on that album. Working with Kevin Shirley was an awesome experience that led to a long and great friendship.
Metropolis Part II is regarded as one of the best Dream Theater album. Does this album happen due to the frustration of Falling Into Infinity? Or was it because of Jordan Rudess joining the band?
There was no frustration with FII. It was a great album in my opinion. Scenes is special for many reasons. It is the first album with Jordan, it is DT’s first concept album and it is the first one produced by Mike and I.
The Great Debate in the album Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence is one of my favorite Dream Theater song in particular the lyric subject is very interesting. Do you strive to write lyrics which are extraordinary or were it simply because it affected you in some way?
I like to experiment with a few different writing styles. Sometimes I tell stories, other times I reflect on emotions or personal events. This was an example of choosing a very controversial topic that would raise questions and get people talking. A reflection of the state of the world at that moment.
How was the guitar/keyboard solos in the song In The Name Of God was written? Amazing!
It is a legato guitar line that I wrote and showed to Jordan. We had the idea of doubling it in unison in order to create a cascading flow of notes.
Octavarium was a little bit laidback. Some argued too many ballads. Was this intentional?
The focus on Octavarium was on composition. Stripping down the external elements and getting to the core. It is a very thematic and melodic album.
Systematic Chaos and Black Clouds & Silver Linings had the same production quality. Do you agree on this statement?
Those two albums were recorded in a very similar fashion with the same team. Although there are consistencies, I believe we learned from SC and that Black Clouds came out better sounding.
A Dramatic Turn of Events is basically a new chapter in Dream Theater's history and it turned up to be an excellent album? Is this going to reflect in the future albums as well?
We will continue to strive to be our best musically in all areas. Songwriting, musicianship, production etc. Meeting those challenges each time will help us to grow as a band.
How's Mike Mangini doing in the band? How long does it take for him to be comfortable in the band?
MM is doing amazingly well. Not only is he a super-human drummer but he is also a great person and fits in perfectly with DT. It seems like he was comfortable from the first day.
One thing I remembered seeing Dream Theater live in action (Adelaide, Australia 2008) was that you had multiple cameras fixed to all the band member's positions, eliminating moving cameraman on stage. However, does it limit the way it turns out in DVD?
Those cameras are just to send images to the video screens. A real DVD shoot would have moving cameras.
I guess, unlike Mike Portnoy, looking at the progress of Dream Theater the last few years, there will be no rest. But perhaps you will need it in the future, in what conditions that can be?
We plan on making music as DT for many years to come.
How do you find playing in Singapore for the last two shows (2006 & 2008)? What it is going to be like in 2012?
We had a great time and I’m so excited to return and not only introduce Mike Mangini to everyone, but to play the new songs and to show off our beautiful stage production.
Asian crowds are not as aggressive compare to others. How do find this affecting your stage performance?
No. It is amazing playing in Asia. We always have the best time and the audiences are spectacular.
Will there be a new DVD with Mike Mangini on it?
Yes, coming soon.
Is anyone going to help Petrucci producing the next album?
No, I will continue to produce DT on my own.
Last words to fans in Singapore, Malaysia and Indonesia?
Thank you so much for the many years of support and love. We are so psyched to be playing for all of you and look forward to sharing many more musical memories in the years to come!
Apa penyebab reunion ARADIA?
Burning Twilight: hmmmmm...sebab utama maybe mission dulu yg terbantut dan belum lagi ada rilisan rilisan genre dark metal yg betul betul ummphhhhh (ini personal opinion saya la Sam).
Cor Draconis: Personally… walaupun hampir 10 tahun saya dalam ‘seclusion’, namun masih into genre muzik ni gak walaupun tak ambil tahu sangat. The fire still burning within… terutama bila mengenangkan tiada lagi hasilkarya yang sebenar daripada kami… Bila sahabat-sahabat saya dalam Aradia mengambil keputusan untuk kembali aktif, saya pun dengan tanpa berfikir panjang terus je bangkit kembali untuk meneruskan perjuangan. Saat sekarang ni memang sesuai, segalanya memang dah di-designed oleh The Grand Architect…
Sampai kemana reunion ini? Satu show? Satu album?
Burning Twilight: Insya allah, if masing masing masih ada kreativiti n idea yg fresh, sampai kami kering idea, kami stop la, buat masa nihh..byk sgt idea idea yg nak di praktikkan dan di ekperimentasikan.
Cor Draconis: Personally, kalau ada jalannya… sampai 2nd, 3rd, 4th album dan seterusnya tanpa berpaling lagi sehingga tiba saat yang mana saya benar-benar tidak mampu untuk melangkah lagi. Saya akan tetap berada di sini walaupun yang lain dah takde nanti, dari awal hingga akhirnya… Till the end bersama sahabat-sahabat dalam Aradia sekiranya mereka sudi :)
Sebelum reunion ini, apa yang dibuat oleh ahli band?
Burning Twilight: hmmmmm...last aradia buat gig pun saya dah tak ingat sangat..tapi sekitar tahun 2001, 2002, saya sessionist drummer untuk band RAVENLORD, SAUTS ALASTOR dan SCROLL 666..selepas balik dari UK tu rasa macam hidup ni berubah saja bila kami semua lost contact so masing masing ada yg kahwin macam aie, cik amat n mat jepp so focus pada kehidupan masing masing saja. Tapi masih simpan stuff stuff lama dan masih dengaq metal lagi, kat situ tak berubah.
Cor Draconis: Hmmm… dalam hidup ni, kita semua pasti akan mengalami cycle of evolution samaada dari segi zahir atau batin… menjadi seseorang yang lebih baik dari sesuatu sudut tertentu, bergantung kepada pelbagai persepsi :) Personally, ketika itu saya lebih menumpukan kepada suatu perkara yang telah menjadi nadi serta nyawa utama saya sekarang ni…
Hala tuju ARADIA, sama atau berbeza dari dahulu?
Cor Draconis: Musically, yup! Ni yang kami nampak secara zahir serta hakikatnya pada past, present dan near future band ni… Distant future lak, takkan ada sesiapa yang tahu… For present dan near future ni, ni la style serta konsep etc yang dah mendarah-daging dengan kami dari our past yang tetap akan kami tonjolkan… Distant future, mungkin kami akan berevolusi for the better, who knows for sure? Death is certain, life is not!
Setelah bersama kembali, apakah 'aura' yang dirasakan? Bersemangat?
Burning Twilight: Lebih bersemangat to be honest ngan hang. Sebab? Facilities studio sekarang lebih canggih dan kami pun dah ada sumber kewangan sendiri untuk survive buat recording etc tak perlu nak bergantung pada org lain macam dulu :-) Local scene dan penerimaan media pun dah open sikit tak macam dulu.
Cor Draconis: Yup! Setelah berevolusi materially dan ethereally selama bertahun ni tiap-tiap individu dalam circle of brotherhood kami lebih bersemangat dan lebih bersedia lagi zahir dan minda walaupun dah tua sikit, hehehe. Life itself is our good teacher… Bring it on :)
Komen sikit mengenai show yang lepas Metal Camp II. Ramai yang merasakan ARADIA berterabur masa tu.Burning Twilight: hmmmm..macamnila Sam, rehearsal tak cukup, nervous after lama dah tinggal, masalah atas stage n masalah masalah lain..just not our day la Sam..itu je..tapi alhamdulillah, crowd masih appreciate la jugak.
Cor Draconis: Suatu yang biasa bagi kami dan orang lain pun secara logiknya… Personally, saya sendiri pun dalam 10 tahun haram tak sentuh langsung instruments etc. Untuk gig tu, kami cuma ada sebulan lebih je nak rehearse, sinkronisasikan balik segalanya etc… one month against many years! Atas stage lak banyak ‘insiden’ yang sudah tentu audience takkan aware etc. Apapun, saya tak suka bagi alasan etc dan tak peduli pun… Saya lebih suka memandang ke future, perbaiki sehabis-daya dengan belajar dari kesilapan semalam… as a fighter :)
Apakah penyebab berkuburnya ARADIA?
Cor Draconis: Seperti yang telah saya terangkan di atas… Ia berkaitan dengan cycle of evolution peribadi setiap individu yang terlibat… Evolved by the greater cause… :)
Scene 'Ramzan'. Apakah yang dapat diceritakan mengenai ini? Ianya agak ekslusif untuk 'pendokong' banc Black Metal Norway.
Burning Twilight: Tak ada scene ramzan pun sebenarnya Sam cuma minat sama antara kawan kawan saja. Kawan kawan yg selalu melepak zaman ada restoran ramzan kat CM tu pun masih ramai yg aktif bermain band, alhamdullilah minat dan semangat tu berterusan (WAR 666 dah rilis first album, IMPERIAL (dalam proses rakam 1st album), ARADIA (insya allah menyusul setelah sahabat kami IMPERIAL settled recording diaorg) dan kekawan lain yang masih aktif main muzik (Zoy CRYPTIC dengan Dewangga Sakti). Masing masing dah evolved tapi music inspiration tu tetap datang dari band band dari scandinavia la jugak.
Cor Draconis: Saya antara orang yang first hang-out kat situ bersama sahabat-sahabat yang lain… Bermula daripada saya telah dihina oleh guard C.M dan juga oleh kerana ‘pandangan sinis’ individu lainnya oleh kerana minat kami kepada genre muzik ekstrim ni. Gelaran Ramzan Horde ni lebih kepada circle of brotherhood dengan tiap-tiap individunya mempunyai kecenderungan serta nilai persahabatan yang sama dan kekal dalam ertikata sebenarnya sehingga ke hari ini walaupun ada di antara kami dah kembali ke baqa’ etc. Kebanyakkan kami telah berevolusi menjadi individu yang mempunyai kepakaran dalam bidang masing-masing yang menjadi aset berharga circle of brotherhood kami… Dan yang paling bernilai sekali tentulah sense of brotherhood yang sudah terjalin di antara kami selama ni… and beyond!
Beza scene Metal underground dulu dan sekarang?Burning Twilight: Hmmmm Sam..underground lagi ka sekarang? Dulu yaa, melepak pun kat underground (komplek yik foong)
Cor Draconis: Agak pelik… terlalu open, mudah etc tak macam dulu… Zaman kita dulu punya la seksa, hahahahaha! Tapi kami adalah flexible :)
Matlamat terdekat (1-2 tahun ni) untuk ARADIA?
Cor Draconis: Teruskan berjuang sehingga akhirnya… album and more album till the end sekira ada takdirnya…

















